Prepping and Writing for the Minerva Grant
- JP Singh
- Jul 7, 2022
- 3 min read
J.P. Singh, Principal Investigator
When Department of Defense’s Minerva Research Initiative issued its Funding Opportunity Announcement last summer, its theme of “Topic 7: Social and Cultural Implications of Artificial Intelligence” resonated with many of us at George Mason University. We are a group of transdisciplinary researchers affiliated with George Mason’s Center for Advancing Human-Machine Partnerships (CAHMP) spanning engineering, natural and social sciences, and the humanities. Puzzling about the social and cultural implications involves thinking about human-machine partnerships, and our team was excited to move forward with crafting a Minerva proposal.
Minerva funded 17 proposals this year. We were delighted to find out that George Mason received two of these grants. The proposals went through two stages of review. In the first stage, we submitted a three-pager in June and were then selected to submit the full proposal end-September.
I would like to use this blog to share with you three take aways from our team on writing our Minerva grant. Short version: Pooling ideas from an interdisciplinary team, and frequent brainstorming with writing and re-writing, we believe, were important for being awarded the Minerva grant.
Let the puzzle guide you on the required transdisciplinarity:
My own research puzzles about the ways cultural values, economic incentives, and institutional priorities influence technology infrastructures. Amarda Shehu and Antonios Anastasopoulos, the two computer scientists on our team, suggested ways in which we could use natural language processing and machine learning tools to build models that could analyze the ways in which a country’s values and institutional priorities are reflected in evolving artificial intelligence infrastructures. Artificial intelligence infrastructures raise a host of ethical questions for any society, in not just what values are inscribed in them but, more importantly, their ethical implications. Jesse Kirkpatrick, trained in ethics of AI systems brought this expertise to our team. Minerva FOAs are clear on the needed security implications for each grant proposal. Mike Hunzeker brought historical and theoretical knowledge to thinking about the implications of technologies for security.
We were also able to bring on board an excellent group of graduate students: Caroline Wesson is working on technology hubs and clusters as part of her dissertation research. Manpriya Dua’s dissertation examines machine learning models. Daniel Ofori-Addo’s dissertation looks at the determinants of ICT infrastructures in Sub-Saharan Africa. After the grant was awarded, Webby Burgess joined the team bringing a background in philosophy and good governance.
Create time for frequent brainstorming and to build transdisciplinary understandings:
Teams across disciplines need time to understand each other’s concepts, methods, and jargon. Our proposal, for example, required a translation of social science analyses into machine learning models. This required some understanding and multiple back and forth iterations on drafts. Description, for example, means something quite different in computer science than it does in social sciences. The task of translating for each other and brainstorming about the proposal’s outline was one of the most intellectually exciting parts of our proposal writing.
Supplementary materials require time and resources:
Polished proposals take a great deal of writing and re-writing the proposal narrative, but also enormous time is taken up with supplementary documents and negotiations across units. Expect to spend time on all these activities. The team came with experienced proposal writers, and everyone understood that while the proposal narrative is the core of the proposal, other documents must also be in place and sometimes take time to generate. Good relationships with grants officers at the department, school, and university level are very helpful.
All in all our team spent four good months last summer and fall writing this proposal. Since receiving our award, the team has started work on our research and will be sharing updates with you monthly via this newsletter and our website on our progress.
Great recap of an exciting opening day with impressive matches and international talent. I also enjoy checking Lotería de Hoy for daily updates. Thanks for sharing this memorable tournament coverage!
I genuinely enjoyed reading this. The writing style makes it easy to stay focused from beginning to end. This is one of those articles that keeps your attention because the information is presented so well. There is a noticeable difference between content written for people and content written just to fill a page, and this clearly belongs in the first category. While looking for additional information, I recently came across https://proshtuchnyiintelekt.com/ and found several useful examples there. I appreciate when content creators focus on practical advice instead of trying to sound overly technical. I found this genuinely helpful and informative. Wishing you continued success with future posts.
This was a surprisingly useful post. I like how you managed to keep the article both informative and engaging. To be honest, I wasn't expecting to learn much when I opened this page, but I ended up reading the whole thing. Many articles cover the same subject, yet they often miss the real-world perspective that makes information useful. During my search for similar resources, I found https://101pryvitannia.com/, which also takes a straightforward and reader-friendly approach. That same emphasis on clarity and usefulness is something I always look for when reading online. In my opinion, more websites should publish content like this. Thanks again for sharing your thoughts.
I genuinely enjoyed reading this. It's refreshing to find content that respects the reader's time while still providing useful information. It's rare to find content that combines clarity, usefulness, and readability this effectively. What stands out here is the focus on helping readers rather than simply repeating common advice. I discovered https://krasatazdorovia.com/ not long ago and was pleasantly surprised by how practical the content was. That same emphasis on clarity and usefulness is something I always look for when reading online. In my opinion, more websites should publish content like this. Wishing you continued success with future posts.
Really interesting read. Everything is presented clearly without oversimplifying the subject. To be honest, I wasn't expecting to learn much when I opened this page, but I ended up reading the whole thing. Many articles cover the same subject, yet they often miss the real-world perspective that makes information useful. While looking for additional information, I recently came across https://novynypoltavy.com/ and found several useful examples there. It's always a good sign when content leaves you with something useful rather than just taking up your time. In my opinion, more websites should publish content like this. Keep up the great work.